American Style Halloween Traditions & Myths


When Pagan Europeans immigrated, they brought their lore and practices to the U. S. Many have been adapted throughout the years. Others are uniquely American creations.

To the Pagan Celts, this festival day is called Samhain. It’s the celebration of the third and final harvest, a time of reflection, and when the boundaries between the living and the dead are the thinnest. Most Hallowe’en traditions are rooted in this Olde Religion’s practices and legends.


This American legend is based on Jack-O-Lantern Irish lore.

In Ireland’s tradition, Jack was doomed to wander about the earth because he was denied entrance to both Heaven and Hell. Samhain Traditions and Lore detail this legend.

According to one Americanized version, Jack sold his soul to the devil at midnight at a crossroads. The pact was that he would have seven years to live as he wanted before the devil claimed his soul.

When the devil came for Jack’s soul, the man asked him to retrieve a shoe he had fastened to a wall. While the devil obliged, Jack nailed him to the wall. He made the devil promise that he would never bother him again before he freed him.

When he died, Jack was denied entrance to Heaven because of his wicked ways and to Hell due to the pact he made with the devil. He was doomed to wander on earth eternally. The devil, after denying Jack entrance to his domain, threw him some fire. Jack’s only diversion was to be enticing people into bogs and swamps at night.

According to Black ethnic lore in the 1800s, Grandpappy got lost in the woods. He saw a light and began to walk towards it, but became lost. He angrily concluded that he was fooled by a jack-ma-lantern (ol’ folks used to insist the middle syllable was “ma”). Grandpappy drew a circle on the path, etched a cross into the ground, turned his pockets inside out, and prayed to expel witches and their jack-ma-lanterns.

Candy Corn

Corn is one of the traditional foods and decorations for the Pagan celebration of Samhain. Enterprising Americans made orange, yellow, and white candy in the shape of a corn kernel.

candy corn

In the 1880s, the Philadelphia-based Wunderle Candy Factory was the first to commercially produce these Halloween treats.

Regional Halloween Traditions

By the turn of the 20th century, different parts of the United States had their own customs and, later, one legendary ghost!

  • People in Louisiana feasted on what they called a “dumb supper” at midnight while watching for a ghost to appear. This wasn’t a foolishly put-together meal. It was a silent one.
  • Residents of New Hampshire held barn dances.
  • In the mountainous regions of North Carolina, it was whispered that people would hear words of the future spoken softly in the wind.
  • There is a legend that the ghost of movie star Humphrey Bogart visits New York every October 31st to warn people not to stay in California too long.
  • New Yorkers, in the city, had parades and fireworks.

black cat in witch pot

Cats (especially black cats), because they were considered a witch’s familiar, an allied spirit in feline form, became associated with Halloween, along with pumpkins and ghosts.

American Style Halloween Traditions & Myths

Available for Amazon Prime